Petoskey is staying — open through the end of 2026

Northern Michigan · Family owned · Est. 2020

Hand-rolled crust. Local fruit. Real pie.

Fruit pies, cream pies, hearty savory pies and a bakery case worth arriving hungry for — from the only shop in the region using hand-rolled crust and local fruit, with counters in Alanson and Petoskey.

“In Pie We Trust” — the sign above the case in Alanson

The bakery's owners standing behind the pie display case under the In Pie We Trust neon sign, with labeled fruit and cream pies in the case IN PIE WE TRUST · SWEET & SAVORY · EST. 2020

Behind the case in Alanson, under the shop’s “In Pie We Trust” neon sign.

Tastemaker pickNorthern Express, Jan 2026
4.3 stars154 Restaurantji reviews
Hand rolledA full case of pies every day
Two shopsAlanson + Petoskey

A place to start

Sweet, savory, and something for the ride home.

Come for the hand-rolled crust; leave with dessert, dinner, and maybe a cookie for later.

Order ahead

Take the pie home with you.

Order whole pies and bakery favorites from the online shop for pickup — baked to order by the same hands behind the case.

Coconut cream pie

Coconut Cream Pie

$39.95

Order
Apple crumble pie

Apple Crumble Pie

$39.95

Order
Strawberry rhubarb crumble pie

Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble Pie

$39.95

Order
Double layer carrot cake

Double Layer Carrot Cake

$48.50

Order
Spiced pumpkin pie

Spiced Pumpkin Pie

$39.95

Order
Chocolate coconut pecan pie

Chocolate Coconut Pecan Pie

$39.95

Order
Raspberry crumble pie

Raspberry Crumble Pie

$39.95

Order
Peach crumble pie

Peach Crumble Pie

$39.95

Order
Black bottom lemon cream pie

Black Bottom Lemon Cream Pie

$39.95

Order
Apple caramel crumble pie

Apple Caramel Crumble Pie

$39.95

Order
Peanut butter pie

Peanut Butter Pie

$39.95

Order
Chocolate silk pie

Chocolate Silk Pie

$39.95

Order
Spinach and feta quiche

Spinach and Feta Quiche

$35.00

Order

Michigan Blend Pie

$39.95

Order

New York Cheesecake

$55.00

Order

Classic Pecan Pie

$39.95

Order

Prices are from the online shop and may change — the shop always shows the current price.

Thanksgiving 2026

The Thanksgiving pie menu.

Eight festive favorites for your family table. Presale ends Saturday, November 21 at 4 PM. Pickup Monday, November 23 through Thursday, November 26 — we’re open Thanksgiving Day 9 AM–12 PM at both stores. $3 from every pie goes to Habitat for Humanity. Download the printable flyer.

Spiced Pumpkin Pie

A timeless classic with smooth, creamy pumpkin custard and a blend of seasonal spices.

$39.95

Order

Michigan Blend Pie

Experience the unique flavors of cherries, apples, and blueberries in every bite.

$39.95

Order

Apple Caramel Crumble Pie

Layers of succulent apples, topped with buttery crumble and drizzled with rich caramel sauce.

$39.95

Order

New York Cheesecake

Dense, creamy, and rich with a buttery graham cracker crust — the timeless classic, done right.

$55.00

Order

Chocolate Coconut Pecan Pie

Indulge in rich chocolate, shredded coconut, and crunchy pecans in this decadent treat.

$39.95

Order

Coconut Cream Pie

Silky coconut custard topped with fluffy whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes.

$39.95

Order

Peanut Butter Pie

A peanut lover’s dream with creamy filling in a crisp graham cracker crust.

$39.95

Order

Classic Pecan Pie

Buttery, gooey filling packed with toasted pecans in our flaky crust — a holiday table must.

$39.95

Order

Order online for pickup — baked to order by the same hands behind the case.

The owners of the Sweet and Savory Pie Company laughing together behind the pie case under the In Pie We Trust neon sign The owners behind the shop counter
Behind the counter in Alanson — family owned and operated, under the shop’s “In Pie We Trust” neon sign.

Our story

Northern Michigan pie, with a wider world inside.

New York–born Oreste started baking pies more than a decade ago in Chicago — and found he couldn’t stop. Together with Deon, from Cape Town, he ran Empanada Mama and The Pie Man in East Lakeview before the two bought the House of Pies in Alanson, which grew into The Sweet and Savory Pie Company. The case holds sweet classics — fruit pies, cream pies — while the savory menu ranges from chicken pot pie to South African curried beef inspired by bobotie.

“Top pie in northern Michigan.” Guest review
Northern ExpressJanuary 2026 “Tastemaker” feature for the Butter Chicken Curry Pot Pie.
Summer 2026Featured in the Northern Express Restaurant Guide, “Eat More Pie.”
CateringAvailable for small to medium groups.
WeddingsWedding pies have been part of past celebrations.

From the people who ate the pie

The crust gets mentioned. A lot.

Short excerpts from public customer reviews.

It’s by far the best cherry pie we have ever tasted!

Wedding customer · October 2024 wedding

The crust was so flaky and tender, yet sturdy... The fruit was the perfect balance of tart and sweet.

Customer review

Lobster Mac & Cheese pie. Lots of real lobster & flavor. Wow!

Customer review
The owners smiling behind the pie case with labeled pies on the shelves below

Gatherings & celebrations

Bring the pies people talk about for weeks.

Catering is available for small to medium groups — talk to the shop directly so everything arrives with the same freshness, quality and presentation you’d find in the case.

  • Catering for small to medium groups
  • Wedding pies for past celebrations
  • Call the shop to plan your order

Come by the shop

Two counters. Plenty of reasons to stop.

Call your preferred location for current selection, catering, or wedding pie questions.

Takeout and in-shop only. Products cannot be shipped. Catering is available for small to medium groups — call the shop to discuss.

Say hello

Get in touch.

Questions about an order, catering, or wedding pies? Send us a note — we read everything.

Call the shops

Alanson — (231) 347-6525
Petoskey — (231) 622-8822

Email us

info@sspiecompany.com

Order ahead

Whole pies and bakery favorites are available through the online shop for pickup.

From our Instagram

Fresh from the ovens.

Seasonal pies, bakery-case arrivals, and shop news — straight from our feed.