We have a new home on the internet — and we built it the way we build a pie: from scratch, with the good stuff front and center.
Here's what's new. You can now order whole pies ahead online — coconut cream, cherry crumb, apple caramel, chocolate silk, our spinach and feta quiche, and more — and pick them up at the shop. No more calling ahead and hoping; browse the pies, place your order, and we'll have it ready.
You'll also find both of our locations here: Alanson on Oden Road and Petoskey in the D&W Plaza, with hours, directions, and phone numbers for each. And if you're planning something bigger — a wedding, a holiday table, a gathering that needs feeding — our catering information is all in one place now.
One note we're happy to share: Petoskey is staying open through the end of 2026. Come see us there while you can.
This little blog is where we'll post shop news — seasonal pies coming into the case, holiday ordering deadlines, and whatever else is happening behind the counter. Check back, or follow us on Instagram for the day-to-day.
Thank you for letting us feed you all these years. Now go order a pie.