Discover handcrafted pie creations for all tastes at our sweet and savory pie company in Petoskey. Whether you crave a delicious sweet savory pie or a unique flavor, our offerings cater to every palate.
At the Sweet and Savory Pie Company in Petoskey, we believe that every pie has a story. Our journey began with Oreste from New York and Deon from Cape Town, who came together to share their passion for baking delicious sweet savory pies. We use only the freshest ingredients sourced from local purveyors to create mouthwatering flavors that keep our customers coming back for more.
Oreste started making pies more than a decade ago in Chicago, primarily for special occasions and celebrations. After living in South Africa for five years, we decided to open our first retail outlet. Our original shop was Empanada Mama and The Pie Man, located in East Lakeview, Chicago. After doing business for about three years, we completely outgrew the space and decided to buy the House of Pies in Alanson, which later evolved into the Sweet and Savory Pie Company. Now, as part of the Sweet and Savory Pie Company in Petoskey, we continue our tradition of crafting delicious pies.
Our food philosophy centers around our passion for using quality ingredients and delivering the best customer service—always! We also have an undeniable love for a good crust. Nothing compares to the anticipation of the first bite of a freshly baked pie with a fantastic butter crust and mouthwatering filling. That’s why our pastry is made in-house, perfected over years of trial and error, ensuring every sweet savory pie meets our high standards.
At The Sweet and Savory Pie Company, we take pride in offering a wide variety of pies. Our pies are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients. We provide classic pie flavors like apple and pumpkin, alongside unique options such as blueberry lavender and salted caramel. Baked to perfection, our sweet and savory pies are sure to satisfy your cravings. Visit us today and find your new favorite pie at The Sweet and Savory Pie Company in Petoskey!
We are conveniently located at the D&W Plaza, 1147 US Highway 31 N, just steps away from the main square. Our cozy shop is the perfect place to grab a dessert pie, cookie, pie slice and even savory pie.